Book excerpt

On Volume 158, theologian Matthew Levering discussed his book, The Abuse of Conscience: A Century of Catholic Moral Theology (Eerdmans, 2021). In the book’s final chapter, “The Path Forward,” Levering contrasts the work of two contemporary theologians whose work presented two very different understandings of the nature of conscience. Levering clearly believes that the description of conscience offered by one of these thinkers — Reinhard Hütter — is more in keeping with conscience as traditionally understood.

Reinhard Hütter was a guest on Volume 149, discussing his book Bound for Beatitude: A Thomistic Study in Eschatology and Ethics (Catholic University of America Press, 2019). The Friday Feature for October 20, 2023, presented a lecture by Hütter entitled “Freedom of Conscience as Freedom in the Truth: Conscience according to Thomas Aquinas and John Henry Newman.”

Here is a precis of Hütter’s ideas about conscience as summarized by Matthew Levering:

“In his 2004 Bound to Be Free, written as a Lutheran ethicist, he [i.e., Hütter] argues that if Christian freedom obeys no universal moral norms, then such freedom is a mere sham. He cannot accept that Christ merely sets us ‘free to do what we want, as long as we have a “good will” (are motivated by the “gospel”) and thereby intend “something good” in what we do.’ He is concerned to counter the modern understanding of ‘freedom’ as lawless and therefore inevitably as ‘the law of our unexamined desires.’ If we simply are called in Christ to follow wherever our hearts lead, then there is no need for a theological discipline of ‘ethics’; ‘moral theology’ as such becomes impossible except as a rubber stamp to whatever the Zeitgeist or our personal desire proposes. Such antinomianism ends by becoming a strict legalism, though now a legalism based upon the unlawfulness of criticizing whatever desires happen to be culturally approved.

“According to Hütter, anthropocentric ethics cuts against Scripture and the tradition’s theocentric, teleological ethics. Moral theology properly has at its center God, active in the creative and redemptive past, in the ecclesial and sacramental present, and in the eschatological future. In fact, freedom and moral flourishing are ordered to God and enabled by God. Such freedom takes shape in virtues and is impeded by vices. Furthermore, it is God’s law — God’s commandments — that instructs us in the path of true (relational) freedom; law and love are correlative.

“Hütter became a Catholic in December 2004, and his first book as a Catholic appeared in early 2012, titled Dust Bound for Heaven. Here, he defends Thomistic hylomorphism as a biblically faithful path between the extremes of angelism and animalism. The key is Aquinas’s awareness that ‘the passions do not act exclusively on the soul, but rather on the whole human composite. According to angelism, the passions merely distract the immaterial intellect’s life; whereas according to animalism (grounded in Epicureanism, Thomas Hobbes, and David Hume), the intellect — here simply material — exists to express and serve the passions. For Aquinas, by contrast, the intellective power governs the passions, making it possible for the passions to offer their proper contribution to the true flourishing ‘of the whole human being’ under the healing and elevating grace of the Holy Spirit.

“In Bound for Beatitude (2019), Hütter examines Aquinas’s theocentric understanding of conscience and prudence. Hütter integrates these topics into the fuller framework of the Christian moral life, including nature and grace, eternal law and natural law, the saving power of Christ’s cross, charity, faith, hope, the virtue of religion, the virtue of chastity, and our hope for resurrection and eternal life. He emphasizes that sinners, headed toward death, need the redemption that Christ brings and the transformative faith, hope, and love that his Spirit imparts.

“Notably, he warns that absent a proper understanding of human ‘finality’ or body-soul ordering toward beatitude, ‘the late-modern person vacillates between the self-image of an essentially disembodied sovereign will that submits all exteriority, including the body, to its imperious dictates, and the self-image of a super-primate . . . gifted or cursed with a developed consciousness that is driven by instincts, passions, and desires beyond its control.’ Real conscience has no place in either of these distorted self-images. Real conscience, after all, judges our actions and often condemns them. Real conscience does not give free rein to a person’s desires.

“What is needed, Hütter says, is for Catholic moral theology to move away from ‘the denial of the finality of nature and the consequent metaphysical evacuation of nature itself.’ By ‘finality’ he means theocentric teleology, our ordering toward the Good, toward God as our ultimate end who brings to fulfillment our body-soul creaturehood by accomplishing in us the real truth of our being. Universal human nature derives from the Creator. Insofar as the human race is a unity, God has given us a nature, whose natural flourishing has distinctive exigencies. The same is true for the ‘supernatural new nature’ that we receive through grace. On the path of beatitude, conscience helps us to recognize our fallenness, to hear God’s moral law regarding our true flourishing, and to pursue this practical truth through the virtue of prudence.

“As Hütter observes, the ‘typically modern crisis of moral motivation’ involves the question: ‘Why should I pursue the good? Why should I be moral in the first place?’ When beatitude is not foregrounded, human beings can feel trapped by human nature and embrace the supposed freedom of either angelism or animalism. Hütter terms this situation ‘subjective sovereignty.’ By contrast, when the Good is firmly at the center, we can see the proper value of synderesis (especially when illuminated by faith) and conscience in communicating to us the eternal law. We can recognize that conscience’s judgments are not mere condemnations but rather are an opening to repentance and hope. The reason to do the good is that God wants us to share in his joy everlastingly. Christ reveals this to us, but we need conscience to help lead us toward it as a real possibility. This work takes place through supernatural prudence, which the act of conscience serves.”

— from Matthew Levering, The Abuse of Conscience: A Century of Catholic Moral Theology (Eerdmans, 2021)

Related reading and listening

Related reading and listening

Links to posts and programs featuring D. C. Schindler:

Links to posts and programs featuring Junius Johnson;

Links to posts and programs featuring Reinhard Huetter;

Links to posts and programs featuring Fr. Augustine Thompson, O.P.:

Links to posts and programs featuring Louis Markos:

Links to posts and programs featuring William C. Hackett:

Links to posts and programs featuring Thomas Albert Howard:

Links to posts and programs featuring Thomas Pfau:

Links to posts and programs featuring Hans Boersma:

Links to posts and programs featuring Bruce Hindmarsh:

Links to posts and programs featuring J. Budziszewski:

Links to posts and programs featuring Steve L. Porter:

Links to posts and programs featuring Norman Wirzba:

Links to posts and programs featuring Timothy Larsen:

Links to posts and programs featuring Bruce Herman:

Links to posts and programs featuring Rod Dreher:

Links to posts and programs featuring Kevin J. Vanhoozer:

Links to posts and programs featuring Esther Lightcap Meek:

Links to posts and programs featuring Alan Jacobs:

Links to posts and programs featuring Kimbell Kornu:

Links to posts and programs featuring David Lyle Jeffrey:

Links to posts and programs featuring David Setran:

Links to posts and programs featuring Peter Bouteneff:

Links to posts and programs featuring Francis J. Beckwith:

Links to posts and programs featuring Marianne Wright:

Links to posts and programs featuring David W. Fagerberg:

Links to posts and programs featuring William T. Cavanaugh:

Links to posts and programs featuring Michael Ward:

Links to posts and programs featuring Michael Dominic Taylor:

Links to posts and programs featuring Rebecca Konyndyk DeYoung:

Links to posts and programs featuring Robin Phillips:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jonathan McIntosh:

Links to posts and programs featuring Marian Schwartz:

Links to posts and programs featuring Andrew Kaethler:

Links to posts and programs featuring Donald B. Kraybill:

Links to posts and programs featuring Thomas Storck:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jonathan Chaplin:

Links to posts and programs featuring James W. Skillen:

Links to posts and programs featuring Richard Stivers:

Links to posts and programs featuring Mark Regnerus:

Links to posts and programs featuring Emma Mason:

Links to posts and programs featuring Mark Noll:

Links to posts and programs featuring David Ney:

Links to posts and programs featuring Greg Peters:

Links to posts and programs featuring David I. Smith:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jason Paone:

Links to posts and programs featuring Kelly M. Kapic:

Links to posts and programs featuring Eric O. Jacobsen:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jessica Hooten Wilson:

Links to posts and programs featuring James Turner:

Links to posts and programs featuring Matthew Rubery:

Links to posts and programs featuring Simon Oliver:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jason Blakely:

Links to posts and programs featuring Kathryn Wehr:

Links to posts and programs featuring Holly Ordway:

Links to posts and programs featuring Paul Tyson:

Links to posts and programs featuring Matthew D. Stewart:

Links to posts and programs featuring David Sehat:

Links to posts and programs featuring John Durham Peters:

Links to posts and programs featuring Oliver O'Donovan:

Links to posts and programs featuring Nigel Biggar:

Links to posts and programs featuring Margaret Harper McCarthy:

Links to posts and programs featuring Andrew Paul Davison:

Links to posts and programs featuring Alison Milbank:

Links to posts and programs featuring Brian R. Brock:

Links to posts and programs featuring Scott Newstok:

Links to posts and programs featuring Fiona Hughes:

Links to posts and programs featuring R. Jared Staudt:

Links to posts and programs featuring Grant R. Brodrecht:

Links to posts and programs featuring Antonio López:

Links to posts and programs featuring Brent Hull:

Links to posts and programs featuring Matthew B. Crawford:

Links to posts and programs featuring Kerry McCarthy:

Links to posts and programs featuring Robert P. George:

Links to posts and programs featuring Christine Rosen:

Links to posts and programs featuring Scott Cairns:

Links to posts and programs featuring Diana Pavlac Glyer:

Links to posts and programs featuring O. Carter Snead:

Links to posts and programs featuring Steven D. Smith:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jeremy Beer:

Links to posts and programs featuring James K. A. Smith:

Links to posts and programs featuring Richard Weikart:

Links to posts and programs featuring Mark Evan Bonds:

Links to posts and programs featuring Perry L. Glanzer:

Links to posts and programs featuring Dana Gioia:

Links to posts and programs featuring Thomas E. Bergler:

Links to posts and programs featuring Susan Srigley:

Links to posts and programs featuring J.A.C. Redford:

Links to posts and programs featuring Carl Elliott:

Links to posts and programs featuring Victor Lee Austin:

Links to posts and programs featuring Sørina Higgins:

Links to posts and programs featuring Steve Wilkens:

Links to posts and programs featuring Gilbert Meilaender:

Links to posts and programs featuring Martin X. Moleski:

Links to posts and programs featuring Brendan Sweetman:

Links to posts and programs featuring Allan C. Carlson:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jason M. Baxter:

Links to posts and programs featuring Barrett Fisher II:

Links to posts and programs featuring Paul Weston:

Links to posts and programs featuring Steven Knepper:

Links to posts and programs featuring Susan M. Felch:

Links to posts and programs featuring Fred Turner:

Links to posts and programs featuring Matthew Dickerson:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jack R. Baker:

Links to posts and programs featuring W. Bradford Wilcox:

Links to posts and programs featuring Bill Vitek:

Links to posts and programs featuring Adam K. Webb:

Links to posts and programs featuring Mark Bauerlein:

Links to posts and programs featuring Felicia Wu Song:

Links to posts and programs featuring Joseph E. Davis:

Links to posts and programs featuring Thaddeus Kozinski:

Links to posts and programs featuring Craig M. Gay:

Links to posts and programs featuring Mark T. Mitchell:

Links to posts and programs featuring Karen Dieleman:

Links to posts and programs featuring Tim Clydesdale:

Links to posts and programs featuring J. Mark Bertrand:

Links to posts and programs featuring Mathew Levering:

Links to posts and programs featuring Mark G. Malvasi:

Links to posts and programs featuring Kirk Farney:

Links to posts and programs featuring Bradley J. Birzer:

Links to posts and programs featuring Ralph C. Wood:

Links to posts and programs featuring Paul Heintzman:

Links to posts and programs featuring Gil Bailie:

Links to posts and programs featuring Zygmunt Bauman:

Links to posts and programs featuring Matthew Lee Anderson:

Links to posts and programs featuring Mike Aquilina:

Links to posts and programs featuring Bishop Robert Barron:

Links to posts and programs featuring Frederick Buechner:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jeffrey Bilbro:

Links to posts and programs featuring James A. Herrick:

Links to posts and programs featuring Andrew Wilson:

Links to posts and programs featuring Susan Cain:

Links to posts and programs featuring Marilyn McEntyre:

Links to posts and programs featuring Andrew Spencer:

Links to posts and programs featuring Albert Borgmann:

Links to posts and programs featuring Catherine Prescott:

Links to posts and programs featuring Maggie M. Jackson:

Links to posts and programs featuring Garret Keizer:

Links to posts and programs featuring Andy Crouch:

Links to posts and programs featuring Kyle Hughes:

Links to posts and programs featuring Philip G. Ryken:

Links to posts and programs featuring Eric Miller:

Links to posts and programs featuring Ted Prescott:

Links to posts and programs featuring Landon Loftin:

Links to posts and programs featuring Barry Hankins:

Links to posts and programs featuring Quentin Schultze:

Links to posts and programs featuring Dale Ahlquist:

Links to posts and programs featuring Paul Walker:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jason Peters:

Links to posts and programs featuring Fr. Damian Ference:

Links to lectures and commentary by Ken Myers: