“Almost thirty years ago Professor Phelps Brown, in his presidential address to the Royal Economic Society, talked about ‘The Underdevelopment of Economics.’ He complained about ‘the smallness of the contribution’ made by the most conspicuous developments of economics to the solution of pressing problems such as inflation, environmental protection, overseas development, urbanization, and the quality of life.

“Schumacher believed that the preoccupation of economists with logical, mathematical and econometric subtleties had led to the almost total neglect of crucial determining factors. If economics was to play any meaningful part in solving the most pressing problems facing humanity and the planet it would have to look beyond the purely economic to the wider questions of life which give economics its purpose, In other words, to become truly relevant, economics must look beyond itself: the ‘how’ of economics needs to be reconciled with the ‘why’ of human existence. Economics needs to become meta-economics. Nowhere has this bedrock reality been discussed more lucidly and potently than in Schumacher’s Small Is Beautiful. . . .

“Schumacher divided meta-economics into three distinct areas. In the first place, economics needs a metaphysical critique of itself, an examination of its intrinsic purpose. Secondly, there is a need on the part of economics to recognize that the physical factors of life are essentially qualitative as well as quantitative. Finally, economics needs to study man in his wholeness and not consider him only as ‘economic man,’ since homo economicus is an abstraction devoid of essential humanity.

“The fundamental error of modern economics is its mechanistic approach. It has evolved ever more intransigently in a merely quantitative direction, erecting econometric models based on mathematical theory which assume that the actions of people are essentially the same as the behavior of atoms. Yet are the ‘facts’ of economics in their essential nature the same as the facts of mathematics or physics? Are human beings, the dramatis personae of economics, similar to atoms in their essential nature? If so, does this not strip humanity of its freedom, its responsibility, its creativeness, its purpose, its meaning? In essence, does it not strip humanity of its humanity? For Schumacher, such questions were at the heart of meta-economics: ‘If economists continue to refuse to face such fundamental metaphysical — or, if you prefer the term, philosophical — questions, I cannot see that they can have any idea of what they are really teaching and what is the relationship of their teaching to truth.’

“Failure to address metaphysical questions has led to many of the central errors of conventional economics. The preoccupation with the physical as opposed to the metaphysical, the quantitative as opposed to the qualitative, has many practical ramifications. For example, the economic obsession with the quantitative has led to price eclipsing value, since price is quantitative whereas value is qualitative. Price is measurable mechanically whereas value can only be evaluated by making value judgments based on philosophical concepts. Since conventional economics shuns these meta-economic concepts, it speaks of ‘value’ only in terms of the market — and ‘market value’ is merely another way of saying ‘price.’ Therefore, intrinsic value does not exist for conventional economics.

“The consequences of this lack of distinction between price and value are far-reaching. As discussed in previous chapters, it has led to a failure to differentiate between primary and secondary goods, or between renewable and nonrenewable goods. It has led to the purely quantitative pricing of the economy in terms of gross national product, ‘which adds everything together, whether it is good or bad, healthy or unhealthy, life-sustaining or life-destroying.’

“Similarly, it has fuelled the idea of the ‘free market.’ Since the market is measured only in terms of price it is assumed that the consumer makes only price-induced judgments. In theory at least, the ideal consumer is a bargain-hunter who is concerned with nothing but price. Consumers do not care whether the goods they are buying are home produced or imported, renewable or non-renewable, organic or chemical, natural or genetically modified, cruelly or humanely produced. Consumers who make any of these value judgments prior to making a purchase are not behaving according to the econometric price mechanism that governs economic theory. They are not behaving as homo economicus should. They have stepped out of line by bringing into the equation value as opposed to price, quality as opposed to quantity, and metaphysics as opposed to physics. They are behaving not as predictable atoms, but as free-willed human beings. By making choices according to supraeconomic standards, people confound the expectations of economic forecasts.

“Clearly, economics needs to be alive to its disciplinary limitations, resisting the academic specialization that isolates it from its traditional roots in ethics and a metaphysical conception of man. It needs to acknowledge the eternally radical statement that ‘Man shall not live by bread alone. . . .’ and to recognize that life is not just a science but an art. In short, if economics is to have any useful or meaningful role, it needs to have a meta-economic ‘soul.’”

— from Joseph Pearce, Small Is Still Beautiful: Economics As If Families Mattered (ISI Books, 2006)

Related reading and listening

Related reading and listening

Links to posts and programs featuring D. C. Schindler:

Links to posts and programs featuring Junius Johnson;

Links to posts and programs featuring Reinhard Huetter;

Links to posts and programs featuring Fr. Augustine Thompson, O.P.:

Links to posts and programs featuring Louis Markos:

Links to posts and programs featuring William C. Hackett:

Links to posts and programs featuring Thomas Albert Howard:

Links to posts and programs featuring Thomas Pfau:

Links to posts and programs featuring Hans Boersma:

Links to posts and programs featuring Bruce Hindmarsh:

Links to posts and programs featuring J. Budziszewski:

Links to posts and programs featuring Steve L. Porter:

Links to posts and programs featuring Norman Wirzba:

Links to posts and programs featuring Timothy Larsen:

Links to posts and programs featuring Bruce Herman:

Links to posts and programs featuring Rod Dreher:

Links to posts and programs featuring Kevin J. Vanhoozer:

Links to posts and programs featuring Esther Lightcap Meek:

Links to posts and programs featuring Alan Jacobs:

Links to posts and programs featuring Kimbell Kornu:

Links to posts and programs featuring David Lyle Jeffrey:

Links to posts and programs featuring David Setran:

Links to posts and programs featuring Peter Bouteneff:

Links to posts and programs featuring Francis J. Beckwith:

Links to posts and programs featuring Marianne Wright:

Links to posts and programs featuring David W. Fagerberg:

Links to posts and programs featuring William T. Cavanaugh:

Links to posts and programs featuring Michael Ward:

Links to posts and programs featuring Michael Dominic Taylor:

Links to posts and programs featuring Rebecca Konyndyk DeYoung:

Links to posts and programs featuring Robin Phillips:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jonathan McIntosh:

Links to posts and programs featuring Marian Schwartz:

Links to posts and programs featuring Andrew Kaethler:

Links to posts and programs featuring Donald B. Kraybill:

Links to posts and programs featuring Thomas Storck:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jonathan Chaplin:

Links to posts and programs featuring James W. Skillen:

Links to posts and programs featuring Richard Stivers:

Links to posts and programs featuring Mark Regnerus:

Links to posts and programs featuring Emma Mason:

Links to posts and programs featuring Mark Noll:

Links to posts and programs featuring David Ney:

Links to posts and programs featuring Greg Peters:

Links to posts and programs featuring David I. Smith:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jason Paone:

Links to posts and programs featuring Kelly M. Kapic:

Links to posts and programs featuring Eric O. Jacobsen:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jessica Hooten Wilson:

Links to posts and programs featuring James Turner:

Links to posts and programs featuring Matthew Rubery:

Links to posts and programs featuring Simon Oliver:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jason Blakely:

Links to posts and programs featuring Kathryn Wehr:

Links to posts and programs featuring Holly Ordway:

Links to posts and programs featuring Paul Tyson:

Links to posts and programs featuring Matthew D. Stewart:

Links to posts and programs featuring David Sehat:

Links to posts and programs featuring John Durham Peters:

Links to posts and programs featuring Oliver O'Donovan:

Links to posts and programs featuring Nigel Biggar:

Links to posts and programs featuring Margaret Harper McCarthy:

Links to posts and programs featuring Andrew Paul Davison:

Links to posts and programs featuring Alison Milbank:

Links to posts and programs featuring Brian R. Brock:

Links to posts and programs featuring Scott Newstok:

Links to posts and programs featuring Fiona Hughes:

Links to posts and programs featuring R. Jared Staudt:

Links to posts and programs featuring Grant R. Brodrecht:

Links to posts and programs featuring Antonio López:

Links to posts and programs featuring Brent Hull:

Links to posts and programs featuring Matthew B. Crawford:

Links to posts and programs featuring Kerry McCarthy:

Links to posts and programs featuring Robert P. George:

Links to posts and programs featuring Christine Rosen:

Links to posts and programs featuring Scott Cairns:

Links to posts and programs featuring Diana Pavlac Glyer:

Links to posts and programs featuring O. Carter Snead:

Links to posts and programs featuring Steven D. Smith:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jeremy Beer:

Links to posts and programs featuring James K. A. Smith:

Links to posts and programs featuring Richard Weikart:

Links to posts and programs featuring Mark Evan Bonds:

Links to posts and programs featuring Perry L. Glanzer:

Links to posts and programs featuring Dana Gioia:

Links to posts and programs featuring Thomas E. Bergler:

Links to posts and programs featuring Susan Srigley:

Links to posts and programs featuring J.A.C. Redford:

Links to posts and programs featuring Carl Elliott:

Links to posts and programs featuring Victor Lee Austin:

Links to posts and programs featuring Sørina Higgins:

Links to posts and programs featuring Steve Wilkens:

Links to posts and programs featuring Gilbert Meilaender:

Links to posts and programs featuring Martin X. Moleski:

Links to posts and programs featuring Brendan Sweetman:

Links to posts and programs featuring Allan C. Carlson:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jason M. Baxter:

Links to posts and programs featuring Barrett Fisher II:

Links to posts and programs featuring Paul Weston:

Links to posts and programs featuring Steven Knepper:

Links to posts and programs featuring Susan M. Felch:

Links to posts and programs featuring Fred Turner:

Links to posts and programs featuring Matthew Dickerson:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jack R. Baker:

Links to posts and programs featuring W. Bradford Wilcox:

Links to posts and programs featuring Bill Vitek:

Links to posts and programs featuring Adam K. Webb:

Links to posts and programs featuring Mark Bauerlein:

Links to posts and programs featuring Felicia Wu Song:

Links to posts and programs featuring Joseph E. Davis:

Links to posts and programs featuring Thaddeus Kozinski:

Links to posts and programs featuring Craig M. Gay:

Links to posts and programs featuring Mark T. Mitchell:

Links to posts and programs featuring Karen Dieleman:

Links to posts and programs featuring Tim Clydesdale:

Links to posts and programs featuring J. Mark Bertrand:

Links to posts and programs featuring Mathew Levering:

Links to posts and programs featuring Mark G. Malvasi:

Links to posts and programs featuring Kirk Farney:

Links to posts and programs featuring Bradley J. Birzer:

Links to posts and programs featuring Ralph C. Wood:

Links to posts and programs featuring Paul Heintzman:

Links to posts and programs featuring Gil Bailie:

Links to posts and programs featuring Zygmunt Bauman:

Links to posts and programs featuring Matthew Lee Anderson:

Links to posts and programs featuring Mike Aquilina:

Links to posts and programs featuring Bishop Robert Barron:

Links to posts and programs featuring Frederick Buechner:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jeffrey Bilbro:

Links to posts and programs featuring James A. Herrick:

Links to posts and programs featuring Andrew Wilson:

Links to posts and programs featuring Susan Cain:

Links to posts and programs featuring Marilyn McEntyre:

Links to posts and programs featuring Andrew Spencer:

Links to posts and programs featuring Albert Borgmann:

Links to posts and programs featuring Catherine Prescott:

Links to posts and programs featuring Maggie M. Jackson:

Links to posts and programs featuring Garret Keizer:

Links to posts and programs featuring Andy Crouch:

Links to posts and programs featuring Kyle Hughes:

Links to posts and programs featuring Philip G. Ryken:

Links to posts and programs featuring Eric Miller:

Links to posts and programs featuring Ted Prescott:

Links to posts and programs featuring Landon Loftin:

Links to posts and programs featuring Barry Hankins:

Links to posts and programs featuring Quentin Schultze:

Links to posts and programs featuring Dale Ahlquist:

Links to posts and programs featuring Paul Walker:

Links to posts and programs featuring Jason Peters:

Links to posts and programs featuring Fr. Damian Ference:

Links to lectures and commentary by Ken Myers: