In 2016, historians Thomas Albert Howard and Mark Noll edited an anthology titled Protestantism after 500 Years (Oxford University Press). Carlos Eire’s essay in this book is called “Redefining the Sacred and the Spiritual: How the Protestant Reformation Really Did Disenchant the World.” The following paragraphs summarize one of the main themes frequently addressed by Mars Hill Audio.
“If one turns to the metaphysical concepts championed by Protestants — concepts that were philosophical and theological, but had immense practical ramifications — the Protestant Reformation can be seen as a major cultural shift, and a crucial step in the secularization of the world, as long as the term ‘secularization’ is not understood too narrowly, along lines that confuse it with the current state of church/state relations in the twenty-first-century Western world. Instead, ‘secularization’ should be understood as a process whereby the realm of the sacred was redefined and contained within a more constricted sphere, both privately and publicly. These conceptual shifts just mentioned point more directly to ‘desesacralization’ than what we common understand as ‘secularization’ in our own day — that is they manifest a reinterpretation of the sacred and its place in human life rather than a redefinition of the magic/religion dialectic or the relation between church and state. These conceptual shifts redefine one of the crucial elements of every civilization: the way in which ontological categories are sorted and reality is conceived.
“The fact that these abstract concepts were perceived by Reformation era Catholics and Protestants as essential markers of the difference between each other is telling. So is the fact that this perceived difference referred to the divine and supernatural, not the demonic and preternatural, or the ‘religio-magical.’ As Catholics and Protestants understood it, what divided them was a different understanding of the sacred, not the demonic or magical.
“But how, exactly, did this paradigm shift take shape?
“First and foremost, the great ontological difference between the physical and spiritual realms upheld by Protestants, especially in the Reformed tradition, drove a wedge between matter and spirit. Iconoclasm was its initial manifestation, but it extended much further than religious imagery, to other symbols: shrines, relics, the Eucharist, and all rituals. The most extreme version of this reinterpretation of matter and spirit found voice in the Reformed Protestant tradition, and in two of its guiding principles: finitum non est infiniti (the finite cannot contain the infinite), and quantum sensui tribueris tantum spiritui dextraxeris (the physical detracts from the spiritual).
“Second, despite the differences among them, Protestants redrew the boundaries between natural and supernatural, and rejected the commonplace irruptions of the sacred favored in medieval religion. In other words, Protestants largely rejected post-biblical miracles, and especially those practically-oriented supernatural events that historians now classify as thaumaturgy. God could work miracles, certainly, and the Bible was full of them, but as Protestants saw it, the age of miracles had passed and God’s direct supernatural interventions were a thing of the past, strictly limited to biblical times. What is more, with just a few exceptions among more radical sixteenth-century movements, Protestants denied the possibility of mystical ecstasies, visions, apparitions, revelations, levitations, bilocations, and all other supernatural phenomena associated with intimate encounters between the human and the divine.
“Relying on the original meaning of the word secular (Latin: saeculum = ‘this age’ or ‘earthly time’), one can argue that these changes contributed substantially to the secularization of the West by creating societies that were more this-worldly than ever before — societies that rejected the medieval sub specie aeternitatis worldview in which human existence in all history had an eternal and supernatural backdrop. In essence, then, this ‘secularizing’ is much more than just a circumscribing of the role of religion in the public sphere. It is a circumscribing of the sacred, and the emergence of a new understanding of reality itself.
“These paradigm shifts were much more than a mere change in thinking or in worldview. They also had a profound and immediate impact on the cultural, social, economic, and political structure of Protestant communities — and on Western Europe as a whole.
“The Protestant Reformation was a metaphysical and epistemic revolution, a new way of interpreting reality and of approaching the ultimate. To put it in the simplest terms, it re-drew the boundaries between heaven and earth, the sacred and the profane.”
Related reading and listening
- A metaphysics of realism, relationality, and personalism — John Milbank gives a survey and critique of the efforts of 20th and 21st century theologians to articulate a Trinitarian ontology that reflects reality and counters secularization. (61 minutes)
- Mars Hill Audio Journal, Volume 162 — FEATURED GUESTS: Mark Noll, R. Jared Staudt, Paul Weston, William C. Hackett, Hans Boersma, and David Paul Baird
- Early evangelical response to C. S. Lewis — Historian Mark Noll discusses the reasons why American evangelicals were initially slow to warm to Lewis. (15 minutes)
- Insisting that political leaders are incapable of obeying Christ — Oliver O’Donovan on the unintended consequences of the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.
- How Christianity crossed the Atlantic — FROM VOL. 55 Mark Noll describes the different form that the Christian faith and the life of churches took when Christianity migrated to North America. (16 minutes)
- An unwitting agent for the secularization of America — Mark Noll, Nathan Hatch, and George Marsden explain how a prominent Christian Founding Father added momentum to the secularization of America
- The unintended consequences of the Reformation — FROM VOL. 114 Historian Brad Gregory discusses the unintended consequences of the Reformation, consequences which continue to trouble us. (26 minutes)
- Noll, Mark — FROM THE GUEST PAGE: Mark Noll is Emeritus Professor of History, University of Notre Dame and Wheaton College. A prolific author, Noll’s publications cover a wide range of topics of interest to evangelicalism.
- Howard, Thomas Albert — FROM THE GUEST PAGE: Thomas Albert (Tal) Howard is Professor of Humanities and History and holder of the Phyllis and Richard Duesenberg Chair in Christian Ethics at Valparaiso University.
- Everything about everything comes from God — Theologian Andrew Davison discusses how the idea of participation informs our understanding of God, of Creation, of being, of knowing, of loving, of law, of economics, etc. (28 minutes)
- An outrageous idea? — In the late 1990s, George M. Marsden and James Tunstead Burtchaell both wrote books examining the claim that it was far-fetched even to imagine that scholarly work could be an expression of Christian claims about reality. (25 minutes)
- Christian scholars and the secularized academy — Mark Noll on why Christian intellectual vitality requires a vision for the universality of Christian truth
- The future of Christian learning — Historian Mark Noll insists that for Christian intellectual life to flourish, a vision for comprehensive and universal social and cultural consequences of the Gospel has to be assumed. (18 minutes)
- Earthly things in relation to heavenly realities — In this lecture, Ken Myers argues that the end of education is to train students to recognize what is really real. The things of this earth are only intelligible in light of heavenly realities. (59 minutes)
- On Earth as it is in Heaven — FROM VOL. 108Hans Boersma — author of Heavenly Participation: The Weaving of a Sacramental Tapestry — explains why Christians should reject the modern separation of Heaven and Earth and recover a “sacramental ontology.” (26 minutes)
- Mars Hill Audio Journal, Volume 158 — FEATURED GUESTS:
David Setran, Vigen Guroian, Michael Dominic Taylor, Thomas Pfau, Jason Paone, and Matthew Levering
- Mars Hill Audio Journal, Volume 156 — FEATURED GUESTS:
Kimbell Kornu, Paul Tyson, Mark Noll, David Ney, William C. Hackett, and Marian Schwartz
- Beyond proof-texts — Mark Noll argues that the distinctly American practice of interpreting the Bible through proof-texting hampered the abolitionist movement’s effectiveness. (41 minutes)
- Republican freedom — and ideological flexibility — Mark Noll on the novelty of America’s Christian republicanism
- The Church and the powers that be — Historian Mark Noll summarizes Christian ideas about political life in the last few centuries, examining how those ideas were worked out in various contexts in Western Europe and North America. (39 minutes)
- Aspects of our un-Christening — In this Friday Feature — presented courtesy of Biola University — Carlo Lancellotti talks with Aaron Kheriaty about the central ideas in Augusto Del Noce’s writings. (43 minutes)
- Faith born of wonder — Theologian Andrew Davison echoes a theme in the work of G. K. Chesterton, describing the work of apologetics as awakening a sense of wonder in the reality of Creation as a beautiful gift. (23 minutes)
- Shrinking sources of causality — David Bentley Hart on the loss of a recognition of inherent meaning in the natural world
- Cosmology without God — Modern science is practiced in the context of beliefs that are intrinsically metaphysical and theological, even though practitioners of science claim (and usually genuinely believe) that their disciplines are philosophically neutral. David Alcalde challenges such claims within a sub-field of astrophysics. (21 minutes)
- The scantily clad public square — Reinhard Hütter on the necessity of the virtue of religion
- The reality that science cannot see — Philosopher Paul Tyson illustrates features of daily life that science cannot “see,” such as love, friendship, justice, and hope, and argues that such things are nonetheless real. (20 minutes)
- Recovering the meaning of reason — James Peters discusses how Plato, Aristotle, Augustine, Pascal, and many others understood the nature and purpose of reason quite differently from the common modern understanding. Also, D. C. Schindler explains how consciousness and reason necessarily involve reaching outside of ourselves. (24 minutes)
- Why “Creation” is more than “origins” — In this archive interview from Volume 121 of the Journal, Michael Hanby talks about why we shouldn’t assume that science can ever be philosophically and theologically neutral. (32 minutes)
- James Matthew Wilson: “T. S. Eliot: Culture and Anarchy” — James Matthew Wilson examines T. S. Eliot’s cultural conservatism and religious conversion in light of his intellectual and familial influences. (79 minutes)
- Questioning the “sacred-secular” division — With the stage set by Michael Sandel, Jean Bethke Elshtain, David L. Schindler, and John Milbank, Andrew Willard Jones examines a medieval alternative to the modern liberal paradigm. (61 minutes)
- Mars Hill Audio Journal, Volume 143 — FEATURED GUESTS:
Mark Regnerus, Jessica Hooten Wilson, John Henry Crosby, John F. Crosby, Wynand De Beer, and Sørina Higgins
- David Martin on what happened in the 1960s — David Martin talks about how the cultural shifts of the 1960s were the fruition of previous changes in the 1890s and 1930s. (17 minutes)
- Mars Hill Audio Journal, Volume 141 — FEATURED GUESTS:
Grant Wythoff, Susanna Lee, Gerald R. Mcdermott, Carlos Eire, Kelly Kapic, and James Matthew Wilson
- Martin Luther, Printing, and the Making of the Reformation — Historian Andrew Pettegree (Brand Luther: 1517, Printing, and the Making of the Reformation) describes how Luther’s facility for writing in German and his intuitive business sense spread ideas and transformed the distribution model of the printing industry. (55 minutes)
- The essential meaning at the heart of reality — Paul Tyson discusses how the modern preoccupation with doing has distracted us from the meaning of being. To meet the cultural challenges of our moment believers must recovery the ontological richness of the premodern Christian heritage. (21 minutes)
- The mythic song of modernity — In his book Returning to Reality, philosopher Paul Tyson imagines a grand “Song of Modernity.” In it, he captures the triumphant sense of enlightenment characteristic of modern thought. Ken Myers summarizes some of the key themes in Tyson’s book. (17 minutes)
- Mars Hill Audio Journal, Volume 137 — FEATURED GUESTS:
Gilbert Meilaender, James L. Nolan, Joel Salatin, Michael Di Fuccia, Robin Leaver, and Michael Marissen
- Mars Hill Audio Journal, Volume 136 — FEATURED GUESTS:
Thomas Albert Howard, Mark Noll, Andrew Pettegree, Peter J. Leithart, Norm Klassen, James Litton, and Joseph O’Brien
- Peter J. Leithart: The Cultural Consequences of Christian Division — Peter J. Leithart discusses how the sixteenth-century Colloquy of Marburg shifted the understanding of the Eucharist from something that Christians primarily do together to something about which Christians think or believe a certain way. (69 minutes)
- Is religion just moralistic therapy after all? — Alexander Schmemann on the secularization of religion
- From darkness [sic] into light [sic] — David Bentley Hart on the ignorant myth that banishes the transcendent from modern public spaces
- In praise of the reality of things — Kenneth L. Schmitz on the dissolving effects of modern modes of thought
- The religious character of medieval secular life — John Milbank on the sacred canopy of premodern Europe
- Not “mere” matter — David Bentley Hart on the spirituality of the material world
- Modernity’s fateful encounter with weird, wayward sisters — Richard Weaver describes the cultural consequences of a decisive metaphysical mistake
- The danger of a self-marginalizing religion — Alasdair MacIntyre on how the task of religion is to help see the secular as the sacred, the world as under God.
- Mars Hill Audio Journal, Volume 121 — FEATURED GUESTS:
Daniel Gabelman, Curtis White, Michael Hanby, Alan Jacobs, James K. A. Smith, Bruce Herman, and Walter Hansen
- Religion for Sundays only — Walter Kasper on how secularization did not eliminate religion, but made it but one sector of modern life along with many others.
- Mars Hill Audio Journal, Volume 115 — FEATURED GUESTS: Arlie Russell Hochschild, Andrew Davison, Adrian Pabst, Gary Colledge, Linda Lewis, and Thomas Bergler
- Mars Hill Audio Journal, Volume 114 — FEATURED GUESTS: Susan Cain, Brad S. Gregory, David Sehat, Augustine Thompson, O.P., Gerald R. McDermott, and Marilyn Chandler McEntyre
